Exploring the Crumbl Cookies secret menu in October 2025 is an exciting treat for dessert lovers. This hidden menu, also known as mystery or off-menu flavors, offers fun surprises with new versions of classic cookies. The options can change depending on the location, making every visit different. As fall begins, these secret cookies often include seasonal flavors like pumpkin and caramel. Knowing about this secret menu makes your Crumbl experience even more enjoyable.
What is the Crumbl Cookies Secret Menu?
The Crumbl Cookies secret menu includes special cookie flavors that are not officially announced. These hidden flavors appear with the regular weekly cookies. Even though Crumbl doesn’t promote them much, fans get very excited about them. Each store can pick secret flavors based on what local customers like. By October 2025, this secret menu has become more common, with some weeks having one or two surprise cookies. People often post their secret cookie finds on social media, which makes the Crumbl community even more excited.
How the Secret Menu Works
Each Crumbl store chooses its own secret menu items. For example, one store might offer a pumpkin cookie, while another might have a chocolate one. These special items are made in small batches, so it’s best to visit early. The secret menu adds more options to the regular menu without making it too big. You can also ask the staff about what’s available—you might discover something new and delicious.
October 2025 Weekly Lineups with Secret Menu Highlights
Each Crumbl store chooses its own secret menu items. For example, one store might offer a pumpkin cookie, while another might have a chocolate one. These special items are made in small batches, so it’s best to visit early. The secret menu adds more options to the regular menu without making it too big. You can also ask the staff about what’s available—you might discover something new and delicious.
Every Crumbl store picks its own secret menu items. For example, one place might have a pumpkin cookie, while another might choose a chocolate one. These treats are made in small amounts, so it’s smart to go early. The secret menu adds fun new options to the regular menu without making it too crowded. Ask the staff what’s available—you might find a tasty surprise.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Secret Menu | Mystery flavor varying by store, often a fall twist like maple or berry. |
October 13-18 Lineup As of October 14, this current week focuses on pumpkin and chocolate themes, with the secret menu sparking curiosity.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Secret Menu | Hidden dessert, possibly a seasonal pecan pie or cinnamon roll variation. |
October 20-25 Lineup Looking ahead, this week introduces more indulgent options, including recent swaps for freshness.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Secret Menu | Surprise item, such as cereal milk or tres leches cake. |
October 27-November 1 Lineup (Halloween Focus) Wrapping up the month, Halloween brings spooky fun with themed treats.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Secret Menu | Mystery Halloween surprise, like a candy corn fusion. |
| Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie | Timeless option amid the festivities. |
Tips for Enjoying the Crumbl Cookies Secret Menu
To enjoy these hidden treats, try a few easy tips. First, check your local Crumbl app to see what’s available because secret cookies sell out fast. You can also join online groups where fans share spoilers and reviews. Try mixing secret cookies with regular ones to make your own custom box — for example, pair a pumpkin flavor with chocolate for a nice mix. Visit the store in the middle of the week to avoid crowds and get fresher cookies. Lastly, try smaller sizes, like mini cookies, so you can taste more without eating too much.
Recent Updates for October 2025
As of October 14, 2025, some cookie flavors have changed because of popularity. For example, Caramel Apple was replaced by Cereal Milk in later weeks to add variety. New flavors like Tres Leches Cake also appeared in secret menus at some stores. With Halloween coming soon, expect more mystery cookies with fall spices and candies. It’s a good idea to check the app often so you don’t miss these updates.
FAQs
The secret menu has mystery flavors that each store chooses on its own, not the same weekly ones found everywhere.
Ask in-store staff or check social media posts from visitors, as it varies by location and isn’t officially listed.
Yes, most weeks include at least one secret slot, adding surprise to the fall lineup.
Check Also: Is Crumbl Cookies Open on Sunday?